412-271-5770

Metal Roof vs Shingles: Which Is The Most Cost Effective?

standing seam metal roof

When it comes to material options for your roof replacement, the choice between metal roofs and shingles is one of the most significant decisions homeowners face. Both materials offer distinct advantages and disadvantages, and the right choice for your home will depend on various factors, including:

  • Your budget
  • Climate
  • Aesthetic preferences
  • Long-term goals

Our guide will explore the ins and outs of metal roof vs shingles, providing you with the information you need to make an informed decision.

Introduction

metal roof in autumn

When it comes to choosing the right roofing material for your home, there are several factors to consider. Two of the most popular options are asphalt shingle roofs and metal roofs. Both have their own unique benefits and drawbacks, and the right choice for you will depend on your specific needs and budget. In this article, we’ll explore the differences between metal roof vs shingles, including their durability, cost, eco-friendliness, installation time, aesthetics, maintenance, fire and storm resistance, and resale value.

Understanding Metal Roofs

Metal roofs are made from various metals, including aluminum, steel, copper, and zinc. Metal roofing systems include different types such as standing seam, corrugated panels, and metal shingles. These roofs come in different styles and finishes, allowing homeowners to achieve a range of looks from traditional to modern.

Types of Metal Roofs

  • Standing Seam: This type features raised seams that interlock, providing a sleek and modern appearance.
  • Metal Shingles: Designed to mimic the look of traditional shingles, these provide the durability of metal with a more classic aesthetics.
  • Metal Tiles: These replicate the appearance of clay or concrete tiles but are much lighter and more durable.
  • Corrugated Metal: Often used in industrial applications, this type has a distinct wavy pattern and is known for its strength and longevity.
  • Flat Seam Metal Roofing: Consists of large flat sheets with interlocking seams, contributing to its strength and durability. It may be more expensive but requires minimal maintenance.

✅ Advantages of Metal Roofs

  • Durability and Longevity: Metal roofs are renowned for their durability. They can withstand extreme weather conditions, including heavy rain, snow, high winds, and even hail. Many metal roofs come with warranties of 40 to 70 years, far exceeding the lifespan of traditional shingles.
  • Energy Efficiency: Metal roofs reflect solar radiant heat, which can reduce cooling costs by 10-25%. Some metal roofing materials come with reflective coatings that enhance energy efficiency, making them an eco-friendly choice.
  • Low Maintenance: Metal roofs require minimal maintenance compared to shingles. They are resistant to cracking, shrinking, and eroding, and they can withstand heavy snowfall due to their smooth surface, which allows snow to easily slide off.
  • Environmental Impact: Metal roofing materials are often made from recycled content and are fully recyclable at the end of their life. This makes them an environmentally responsible choice.

❌ Disadvantages of Metal Roofs

  • Cost: One of the primary drawbacks of metal roofs is the initial cost. They are typically more expensive than shingles, though their longevity and low maintenance can offset this over time.
  • Noise: Metal roofs can be noisier than other types during rain or hailstorms. However, this can be mitigated with proper insulation.
  • Installation: Metal roof installation requires skilled labor, and improper installation can lead to issues such as leaks. It’s essential to hire experienced professionals for the job, as the complexities associated with metal roof installation can result in higher labor costs and longer installation times.

Understanding Shingles

shingles on a two story house

Shingles are the most common roofing material in the United States. They are made from various materials, including asphalt, wood, slate, and composite materials. Asphalt shingles are the most popular due to their cost-effectiveness and ease of installation.

Types of Shingles

  • Asphalt Shingles: Available in three-tab and architectural styles, asphalt shingles are known for their affordability and versatility.
  • Wood Shingles/Shakes: Made from cedar or other types of wood, these shingles offer a natural, rustic appearance.
  • Slate Shingles: These provide a high-end look and have a long lifespan but are heavy and expensive.
  • Composite Shingles: Made from a blend of materials, these shingles can mimic the appearance of wood or slate at a lower cost.

✅ Advantages of Shingles

  • Affordability: Shingles are generally more affordable than metal roofs, making them an attractive option for budget-conscious homeowners. Asphalt shingles, in particular, are cost-effective and widely available.
  • Aesthetic Variety: Shingles come in a wide range of colors, styles, and textures, allowing homeowners to achieve almost any desired look. This versatility makes them suitable for various architectural styles.
  • Ease of Installation: Shingles are easier and quicker to install than metal roofs. Many roofing contractors are experienced with shingle installation, making it a straightforward process.
  • Repairability: If a shingle roof gets damaged, it is relatively easy to replace individual shingles. This makes repairs more manageable and less costly than replacing sections of a metal roof.

❌ Disadvantages of Shingles

  • Shorter Lifespan: Shingles generally have a shorter lifespan compared to metal roofs. Asphalt shingles typically last 15-30 years, while wood shingles may last up to 30 years. However, this is still significantly less than the lifespan of metal roofs.
  • Maintenance: Shingles require more maintenance than metal roofs. They are susceptible to issues such as moss and algae growth, curling, and cracking. Regular inspections and maintenance are necessary to extend their lifespan.
  • Environmental Impact: Most shingles are not recyclable and end up in landfills at the end of their life. Additionally, their manufacturing process can have a higher environmental impact compared to metal roofs.
  • Vulnerability to Weather: Shingles can be more vulnerable to extreme weather conditions. High winds can lift and tear them off, while heavy rain can lead to leaks if the shingles are not properly installed or maintained.

Comparing Metal Roofs Vs Shingles

But what about the other factors? We’ve broken those down for you as well.

Cost Considerations

  • Initial Cost: Metal roofs have a higher upfront cost, ranging from $120 to $900 per square (100 square feet), depending on the type of metal. In contrast, asphalt shingles typically cost between $100 and $200 per square.
  • Long-Term Cost: While metal roofs have a higher initial cost, their longevity and low maintenance can result in lower long-term costs. Shingles might require more frequent repairs and replacement, potentially increasing overall expenses over time.

Installation

  • Metal Roofs: Installation of metal roofing panels requires specialized skills and tools due to their weight and complexity, which can increase labor costs. Proper installation is crucial to prevent issues such as leaks.
  • Shingles: Easier and quicker to install, shingles are suitable for DIY projects, though professional installation is recommended for optimal results.

Durability and Maintenance

  • Metal Roofs: Extremely durable and low-maintenance, metal roofs, particularly those with metal panels, can withstand extreme weather conditions and last 40-70 years. Metal panels offer ease of maintenance and longevity, making them a superior choice for homeowners.
  • Shingles: While more susceptible to damage and requiring regular maintenance, shingles typically last 15-30 years, depending on the material.

Aesthetic Appeal

  • Metal Roofs: Available in various styles and finishes, metal roofs can achieve different looks from modern to traditional.
  • Shingles: Offering a wide range of colors, styles, and textures, shingles can complement any architectural style.

Environmental Impact

  • Metal Roofs: Eco-friendly, often made from recycled materials, and fully recyclable at the end of their life.
  • Shingles: Less environmentally friendly, with most ending up in landfills. Some manufacturers offer recycling programs, but they are not as widespread.

Noise

  • Metal Roofs: Can be noisier during rain or hailstorms, though proper insulation can mitigate this issue.
  • Shingles: Generally quieter, providing better sound insulation without additional materials.

Weather Resistance

One of the most important factors to consider when choosing a roofing material is its ability to withstand the elements. Metal roofs are generally more resistant to weather damage than asphalt shingle roofs. They can withstand high winds, heavy rainfall, and even hail without sustaining damage. Asphalt shingle roofs, on the other hand, can be more prone to granule loss and damage from extreme weather conditions. However, metal roofs can be more prone to denting and scratching from hail and falling debris.

Resale Value

shingles and stone siding

When it comes to resale value, metal roofs tend to be a more attractive option for potential buyers. Homes with metal roofs tend to sell for slightly higher values than those with asphalt shingle roofs. This is because metal roofs are seen as a more durable and long-lasting option, which can provide peace of mind for potential buyers. Additionally, metal roofs can be more energy-efficient and require less maintenance than asphalt shingle roofs, which can also be a selling point for potential buyers.

Making the Right Choice for Your Roof

Choosing between metal roofs vs shingles roofing ultimately depends on your specific needs, preferences, and budget. Here are some key considerations to help you decide:

Both metal roofs and shingles have their unique advantages and disadvantages. Assess your priorities and consult with a roofing professional to determine the best option for your home. By understanding the characteristics of each material, you can make an informed decision that meets your needs and enhances the value and comfort of your home.

Whether you’re looking for metal or asphalt shingle roof construction, McCormick Renovations is here to help! Contact us today for professional advice for your roof replacement.

Read Up! Our Helpful Blog Posts

leaves and a shingle roof

GAF vs Owens Corning: Tips On Choosing Shingle Brands

Choosing the right roofing shingles is a critical decision for any homeowner. Roofs aren't just about aesthetics—they're your home's biggest protection. In the market…

Keep Reading
TPO roof

7 Commonly Used Commercial Roof Types + Benefits

When it comes to maintaining the integrity of a building, the roof is undoubtedly one of the most critical components. For building owners and…

Keep Reading

Your Hometown Roofing Heroes

Get In Touch

"I still have the sign up in the front yard showing who did our roof."  -  Reece M.

Plus Icon
Share to...